1 July 2005

Would You have Dropped the Bomb?

Tadatoshi Akiba

Tadatoshi Akiba is the mayor of Hiroshima, Japan, and president of Mayors for Peace.

Gar Alperovitz

Gar Alperovitz is Lionel R. Bauman Professor of Political Economy at the University of Maryland at College Park. His books on nuclear matters range from Atomic Diplomacy: Hiroshima and Potsdam (...


Thomas Donnelly

Thomas Donnelly is resident fellow in defense and national security studies at the American Enterprise Institute and former editor of Army Times.

Richard B. Frank

Richard B. Frank is the author of Downfall: The End of the Japanese Imperial Empire (1999), which won the 2000 Harry S. Truman Book Award.

Robert L. Gallucci

Robert L. Gallucci is dean of the Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University and was the lead ambassador responsible for the negotiation of the 1994 Agreed Framework with...


Pervez Hoodbhoy

Hoodbhoy has taught in the physics department at Quaid-e-Azam University in Islamabad for 40 years and now also teaches at...


Martin E. Marty

Martin E. Marty is a Lutheran minister and the Fairfax M. Cone Distinguished Service Professor Emeritus at the University of Chicago.

Mary Palevsky

Author of Atomic Fragments: A Daughter's Questions (2000). She is preparing an archive of her interviews with 25 leading nuclear scientists for the Mandeville Special Collections Library at the...


“All our final decisions are made in a state of mind that is not going to last,” wrote the French novelist Marcel Proust. In 1945, our collective state of mind was despair. World War II touched every inhabitable continent, leaving more than 50 million dead and millions of others as refugees. The conflict had spanned more than half a decade. It would effectively end during an interval of 43 seconds–the time it took for the atomic bomb to explode over Hiroshima after it was released by the Enola Gay on August 6. Three days later, a second bomb was dropped on Nagasaki, followed by Japan's surrender. Sixty years later, we live in a world where the capacity for mass destruction is no longer limited to superpowers–or, for that matter, to nations. Our collective state of mind is one of vulnerability. The bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki are not just historical events but portents of a possible future for any city, anywhere. And it is through that lens that we find ourselves looking back at the decision of President Harry S. Truman and its legacy. With each passing decade, the anniversary of the atomic bombings provokes a debate over whether the United States made the right choice. But this crucial question is almost always considered in the abstract. A far more difficult task is to assume personal responsibility. With that in mind, the Bulletin sought out noteworthy thinkers with backgrounds in history, theology, physics, and diplomacy and posed a single, provocative question: “If the decision had been yours alone to make, would you have dropped the bomb?”