Showdown in Dixie Valley

A battle over a geothermal project pits a tiny toad against renewable energy. Can the planet’s heat be harnessed without risking extinction?

This article is part of a Bulletin special feature on the hazards and potential of geothermal energy. Read Jessica McKenzie's full report »


The Peppermill Resort and Casino in Reno, Nevada, is entirely heated and cooled using geothermal water drawn from a reservoir called the Moana anomaly. (Peppermill)

Casino gambles on geothermal—and wins big

November 7, 2022

By Jessica McKenzie

This article is part of a Bulletin special feature on the hazards and potential of geothermal energy. Read Jessica McKenzie's full report »

The Peppermill Reno Resort is just one of a dozen large casinos in “The Biggest Little City in the World.” It boasts over 1,600 guest rooms, a three-story spa, a fitness center, multiple pools, nine restaurants and 15 bars and lounges, in addition to the 82,000-square-foot gambling space. And virtually every inch, from the pools to the parking ramp, is heated and cooled by geothermal waters, drawn from a depth greater than 4,400 feet below the ground at a rate of 800 gallons a minute in summer, 1,200 gallons a minute in winter.

The resort is located above something called the Moana geothermal anomaly, a low-to-moderate temperature geothermal reservoir that looks, in at least one illustration, a bit like a kidney bean. The Moana geothermal reservoir has been tapped for direct-use geothermal applications going back to the early 1900s. The Peppermill began using the geothermal waters on a modest scale in the 1980s, using them to heat a pool and one wing of the resort. In the mid-aughts, the Peppermill began work on an expansion to add 500,000 square feet to the resort, which presented an opportunity to drastically expand the use of geothermal.

“Engineering talked ownership into gambling with a higher-volume, more efficient system,” John Kassai, the manager of the Peppermill Central Plant & Geothermal operations, explains during a tour of the resort’s geothermal operations.

John Kassai, who oversees the Peppermill’s geothermal operations, demonstrates how a heat exchanger works and pours out a sample of geothermal water. The water in the Moana thermal reservoir can contain sulfate, sodium, silica, bicarbonate, chloride, calcium, potassium, fluoride, magnesium, boron, lithium, and arsenic. (Jessica McKenzie)

It didn’t come cheap: The initial outlay for the geothermal expansion was $9.7 million, and there was no guarantee the water would be hot enough. They needed water temperatures of at least 170 degrees Fahrenheit; the water they found is about 172 degrees Fahrenheit. It was a lucky gamble, but even a bigger win than expected.

“So return on investment, when we did this, was supposed to be five years, correct? We did it in three,” Kassai says. “It paid for itself in three years.”

The last time the Peppermill crunched the numbers, three or four years ago, the geothermal heating system had saved the company $6 million. The carbon emissions associated with heating and cooling the sprawling complex have also plummeted. The two boilers the Peppermill once needed for heating and hot water now sit idle, a backup in case of emergency. (Kassai offered to turn them on as a demonstration, but I didn’t want the unnecessary carbon emissions on my conscience.)

Geothermal heating isn’t so different from geothermal electricity production, in that the geothermal water is put through a heat exchanger to warm a secondary liquid, in this case, more water, which is then used in all the normal heating and cooling applications. So all the water in the hot tubs (and the pools and the showers) is just normal water, not the arsenic-laced liquid drawn from the bowels of the Earth.

The pools at the Peppermill Reno resort may not be filled with geothermal waters, but they are heated by them. (Peppermill)

While the United States is the global leader in geothermal energy production, the country lags behind Europe in direct-use applications, like district heating. According to the 2019 Geovision report by the US Energy Department, as of 2016, the United States had a total installed capacity of 100 megawatts thermal; Europe, on the other hand, had a total installed capacity of 4,702 megawatts thermal in 2015. The geothermal district heating system in Paris, France, reduces the city’s annual carbon dioxide emissions by 120,000 tons.

As cities adopt new climate goals, geothermal district-heating could be one of the ways they meet decarbonization goals. Boise, Idaho, the first US city to use geothermal water to heat buildings, back in the 1890s, announced plans for a significant expansion in 2021 to aid the city in becoming carbon neutral by 2050. At the time, geothermal accounted for about 2 percent of the city’s energy use. Officials said that expanding the system by 40 percent won’t even require drilling new wells—just more piping.

There’s no justifiable reason that geothermal district heating isn’t more common in the United States. Unlike other kinds of geothermal technologies, district heating technology is well-established. A 2021 report on geothermal power production and district heating said the reasons it is cost-competitive in Europe and parts of Asia but not the United States is because of then-low natural gas prices, and a lack of US carbon accounting or incentives for renewable heating and cooling solutions.

“Although there are only 23 U.S. GDH systems in operation today, the barriers to expansion of this sector are primarily political, social, and economic—not technical,” the report concludes.


Continue reading Jessica McKenzie's feature on the hazards and potential of geothermal energy: "Showdown in Dixie Valley."

As the Russian invasion of Ukraine shows, nuclear threats are real, present, and dangerous

The Bulletin elevates expert voices above the noise. But as an independent, nonprofit media organization, our operations depend on the support of readers like you. Help us continue to deliver quality journalism that holds leaders accountable. Your support of our work at any level is important. In return, we promise our coverage will be understandable, influential, vigilant, solution-oriented, and fair-minded. Together we can make a difference.

Share: [addthis tool="addthis_inline_share_toolbox"]

Get alerts about this thread
Notify of

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments